A couple of questions and points to make. Does NY State/City law provide for 'minimum' state wage law for service personel or ist it like MA where service personel does NOT receive state minimum wage? Do you really think that restaurant patrons know the difference between 'Gratuity/Tip' and 'Service Charge' ? I think not. I'll bet that more than 75% of all customers think that this 'service charge' will be paid out to servers (mainly). Which in turn the establishment does not legally have to, since "Service" in this case is not defined. Do you believe customers at Per Se will totally and understandably stop leaving a tip, or will they, as most patrons more often look only at the bottom line Dollar amount, still tip? And, even if they understand it, then at what percent? Also, is it not true, and I stand corrected - as always, that the larger the bill the lesser the "percent" amount of tipping/ Example: Party of six, total bill with tax and beverages $ 900.00 next, three parties of two, each party's bill $ 300.00 I venture to say party of six will tip $ 150.00 (16.7%) and the other three parties will tip $ 60.00 ea. (20%) I do "tip" at 20%, never 'after tax', Cocktails and Cordials/Liqueurs and bottled Wine at 15%. Wine above $ 50.00 - 10%, plus $ 10.00 for the Sommelier/Wine Steward. And if there is a "Service Charge" - NO Tip/gratuity. Does this make me cheap? Remember, I retired after 49 years as Chef. Does that make a difference? You tell me. You can't hurt me - I am not allowed to posess feelings anymore. ← Consumer beware! I agree with Peter. It's time to ask specific questions when encountering such presumption. My heart goes out to those sincerely desiring to make a living, namely hard working men and women who wait tables and aptly serve their guests. Hopefully, each client will be treated with the respect he deserves from management on down, while being empowered to use his head and heart in rewarding good service. Is this part and parcel of the dumbing down of America? Perhaps it's just another "hidden tax." In most professions, full disclosure is not only ethical, but mandated and considerate. Let's demand just that!