Thin Mints, no question! Girl Scout cookies need to be taken for what they are, and loved. No one tries to pass them off as anything else but cheap and delicious. I can eat a whole sleeve of the thin mints in one sitting and they are delicious crushed, and put into homemade ice cream. When I was a kid my mom kept them in the freezer and I'd heat them up on a wall heater and melt the chocolate and eat them.