My Joel Palmer House meals have ranged from good to excellent, depending on what I order. Some things are just more to my taste. In general, appetizers please me more than main courses, at least partly because I am very hungry at the start of the meal. I like the soup and the mushroom tart, but your mileage will obviously vary. Usually the special mushroom appetizer is wonderful, sort of the catch of the day. I did not much like the "Faux Gras". Among the main courses, I have really enjoyed the scallops and the pork though the pork is not a mushroom dish. Service was never less than competent, and was outstanding on a couple of visits. Bill