There are some reasons to be disappointed with Nouveau Sushi (but they're all common to the better Montclair restaurants: too little parking, screaming kids before 8 PM, no concept of how to dampen the noise level), but the food is not one of them. I've been there 5 times now (including last night), and the more adventurous you are, the better your evening will be. Remember, Nouveau is associated, however loosely, with Nobu, and the spirit of that restaurant definitely finds itself in the preparations. At most Japanese restaurants, I almost never order the "assorted sushi" entree because this is usually synonymous with "give me the safest, most innocuous offerings you have." Not here. If you order the "Assorted Sushi alla Nouveau" ($30), you will be given one or two rolls and the rest pieces (about 6 or so). The pieces are the most interesting, as they all have a sauce or some other unusual accompaniment (e.g. tuna with a creamy tofu sauce, yellow tail with serrano peppers, and, my personal favorite, hijiki with aioli). If you're not familiar with the Nobu style, this is a great introduction, and while expensive, it's a fraction of the price of the real thing. For the traditionalists, Nouveau does offer all the usual suspects and does an admirable job. Is the traditional sushi anything special? No, not really, but it's still quite good - at these prices, however, you can easily find comparable sushi for less. The cost of the food is quite expensive (for Japanese that is, but no more than Fascino or other "good" Montclair restaurants), and a couple will probably spend $75 to $100 by ordering two cold appetizers, one hot appetizer, and the assorted sushi. But again, this isn't a "typical" Japanese restaurant. Let the chefs create a "nouveau" dinner for you, and begin an exploration into a whole new way of thinking about sushi. One final note. I didn't read the Times review, but its impact was definitely felt. It was packed last night at 7:30 (we got the last table). I would recommend coming either after 8:30 on a weekday or very early on a weekend to avoid the deafening decibel levels. Also, if you go any other time, a reservation is definitely in order.