165 replies to this topic

[Bunnyhugs]

I got hold of some Briottet creme de violette yesterday and made an aviation as follows:

2 oz plymouth
1/2 oz lemon juice
1/3 oz Maraska
1/6 oz creme de violette

Perhaps the violette could still be cut back a notch but I don't find this massively overpowering. . . I mean I've been waiting years to get hold of violette. I want to be able to taste the stuff thank you very much!

But really. . is there anything wrong with the above proportions? I'd call the drink balanced. It could be drier, but it is hardly sweet.


Also, isn't Rangpur verging on being a liqueur gin? It seems like a weird choice of mixing gin if you are concerned about liqueurs taking over the drink. Just my opinion.

[Chris Hennes]

I tried these proportions in an aviation, and ugh. Too much violette. Way too perfumey.

2oz Gin
1/2oz Lemon Juice
2tsp. Maraschino
1tsp. Creme De Violette

I tried to fix it with more gin and lemon juice, but I still feel like I'm at the opera and breathing in three different kinds of heavily-applied perfume. I'd suggest 1/4 or 1/8 teaspoon instead.

My CdV just came in today so I just made a drink very close to this, except using just under 1/2 oz of Maraschino (Luxardo): it seems to be quite well balanced, with just the barest hint of the perfume from the Violette. This could be because the Luxardo has a more pronounced flavor, or because I used more of it, or both.

[Dan Perrigan]

Hi All.

It's been about a year and a half since the last post, and I figured this thread needed a bump -- for several reasons:

1. R&W Creme de Violette is widely available now. (and I believe they modified their formulation a year or two ago).
2. The Gin situation has changed (new gins, certain ones becoming more expensive)
3. It's my favorite drink.
and
4. Being a brand new member, I never got a chance to participate in the original discussion :)

So here we go again:

I first heard of this drink a couple months ago (in Ted Haigh's "Vintage Cocktails") and knew I had to try it. I found Luxardo Maraschino nearby and then went on a quest for Creme de Violette. I finally found some at Astor Wines in NYC, rushed home, and mixed up a proper Aviation.

Woops. Too sweet.

Then I scoured the net and found some blogs -- and also found eGullet -- and tried the ratios I've seen posted here:

2 oz Plymouth Gin
1/2 to 3/4 oz lemon juice
2 tsp Luxardo
1 tsp R&W Creme de Violette.

I was instantly in love. With these brands and these proportions, this is a perfect drink. Each ingredient reveals itself (sometimes several different times) from smell, to sip, to swallow, to luscious aftertaste. (Mmm, I'm getting thirsty...)

So now I'm hooked. But Plymouth is up over $45/Liter, so I've been testing different gins out. Here's what I've found:

Bluecoat: This is a delicious gin, and makes the best martini (4:1 or 3:1, Noilly) that I've ever had. But it went completely flat in an Aviation.
Tanqueray: Good. But not great. Something is missing.
Gordons: Also kind of flat and, well, gray. The drink equivalent of going from color to black and white.
Beefeater: Almost, (but not quite), as good as the Plymouth. If I wasn't tasting them side by side, I MIGHT not have noticed.

I still haven't found a perfect substitute yet. With Plymouth, this drink SINGS. I'm still trying different gins, as bottles run out.

So now (I hope) the discussion is on. What recipes are you using? What gins have you tried (and what did you think?). Also, for anyone lucky enough to get their hands on a bottle of Creme Yvette, how does that compare in an Aviation?

Cheers,
Dan

[thirtyoneknots]

$45 for Plymouth?! Holy cow, where does it cost that much so I know where not to move to?

The increasing price of Plymouth is sort of insulting when you consider that it could be had for about $13 for a 750 just a few years ago. Locally it is now about double that and I drink a lot less of it than I used to as a result but at $45...well I'm not sure that you could make a dry gin I would pay that much for. Ridiculous.

Beefeaters has become my go-to both at home and at work since it is highly versatile and reasonably priced still. And it does in fact make a lovely Aviation.

[thirtyoneknots]

Oh, forgot to add--I think Boodles is actually my favorite Aviation gin. Something about it's up front florality and relatively short finish works so nicely with violette, which often tastes like something hard to place on the palate but lingers long afterwards.

[KD1191]

Beefeater, I think, has become a standard for price conscious shoppers. Broker's is an excellent sub-$20/750ml gin...often a buck or two cheaper than Beefeater, and offering some variety. Not sure I've tried it in an aviation, but it has some citrus on it, so I think it'd do just fine.

Personally, for my favorite Aviation, I like Leopold's. Also a good deal of citrus, but a bit more exotic (pomelo) and flowery, which is quite nice with the Violette.

[Dan Perrigan]

$45 for Plymouth?! Holy cow, where does it cost that much so I know where not to move to?

Northern New Jersey (I just added it to my profile). Actually, after writing that, I searched again and did find a store not too far from here that has it for $25 for 750ml.

Thanks, Andy, for the Boodles suggestion. And KD1191, for the Leopold's. I'll keep an eye out for them. I haven't seen Broker's around here yet, but remember seeing it in Chicago when I was there last. I've been wanting to try it, too.

Dan

[David A. Goldfarb]

I just picked up a bottle of Luxardo Maraschino from Warehouse Wines and Spirits on Broadway near NYU to try this. 2 oz. Boodles, 1/2 oz. Maraschino, 1/2 oz. lemon juice, shaken with three ice cubes until cold, lemon zest garnish. I think I'm about ready for another one.

Edited by David A. Goldfarb, 22 December 2009 - 05:08 PM.

[John DePaula]

I don't have any creme de violette so I've been using a Violette essence, just a drop or two, and it yields a very nice just perceptible floral note to the Aviation. I think it's quite good.

[John Rosevear]

My sense is that Beefeater has really upped their game in recent years. My default standard at home is Plymouth, and I usually have Boodles (an old college favorite) around, but there's absolutely nothing wrong with Beefeater and I prefer it over many showier (and costlier) bottlings.

[vice]

My sense is that Beefeater has really upped their game in recent years.

This struck me as rather interesting. I've only been familiar with Beefeater for the past few years, so can't comment, but my impression is that Beefeater's reputation has been built on being a stalwart, old reliable sort of product (certainly not a flashy up-and-comer, but I suppose that's what Beefeater 24 is for). For those with perspective, has their product been changing through the recent past?

[Shamanjoe]

I've never really been a fan of Beefeaters, though I can't say for sure why. It's not bad, but it's not great either. Maybe I need to pick up a fresh bottle and try it.

As for Plymouth, I've heard everybody rant and rave about it. but I haven't seen what's so special about it either. I have all the stuff for an aviation, but I haven't gotten around to trying it yet..

I have used Plymouth in other cocktails though, like my old stand-by the Tom Collins and it seems to get lost.. Maybe that works in an Aviation? I'll try the Aviation with a few different gins over the next couple holiday days and let y'all know what I think.

[FireAarro]

I have used Plymouth in other cocktails though, like my old stand-by the Tom Collins and it seems to get lost.. Maybe that works in an Aviation? I'll try the Aviation with a few different gins over the next couple holiday days and let y'all know what I think.

I agree, I find Plymouth gets lost in a lot of drinks. I've found it to work very well in some drinks with Cherry Heering, like both of these drinks, which I heartily recommend.

[Shamanjoe]

I tried the Aviation from Gary Regan's iPhone app Flip N Drink..

Aviation (from Flip N Drink)

1.5 oz gin (Plymouth)
0.5 oz maraschino liqueur (Luxardo)
0.5 oz Creme de Violette (Rothman and Winter)
0.5 oz fresh lemon juice

Shake with ice and strain into a chilled cocktail glass.

It was a bit too dry for my tastes, but still very good. I think maybe it needs a little less Creme de Violette, or maybe a slightly longer shake..

[Corinna]

Finally managed a bottle of Luxardo Maraschino, after reading about it on egullet and many cocktail blogs. Currently enjoying my first Aviation (sans Violette, for now) as much as I knew I would. Indeed greater than the sum of its parts. Excited to play with different gins, etc.

In the spirit of the season, I am so thankful for the like-minded people I've found here, who are so generous with their knowledge.

[Mayur]

Beefeater is the bomb. I do prefer something citric in an Aviation, but we use Beefeater at home all the time (the s/o is an Aviation addict) and it turns out well. I actually prefer varying the recipe to use Yvette instead of the R&W, with occasional deviations to violet syrup (I have a gorgeous French farmer's product as well as the Monin to hand). To be honest, I'm not in love with the R&W Violette, though I feel like their other products (pear, apricot, cherry) are some of the tastiest I've ever had in class.

I do 2 gin: 1/2 lemon: 1/2 simple: 1/2 maraschino : float barspoon violette for my Aviation #1; no garnish. Plymouth is fine with this spec.