150 replies to this topic

[Busboy]

I own two mandolins:  The French-made, stainless-steel Bron Professional requires that the cook devote sufficient time to become proficient in its use.  I use the Börner V-slicer much more frequently.  It’s well-designed & durably constructed from ABS plastic which ensures that it will stand up to tough usage.  The V-slicer is ideal for making rapid processing of vegetables for mirepoix, for slicing apples for tarts, or onions for chowder.  Thin or thick slicing, julienne or batonnet – all in all, a tool which I would recommend for anyone’s batterie de cuisine.

I'm not 100% sure you have to study too much to master the Bron, as we have one and -- unlike our wonderful $25 Asion market number -- I have yet to take a fingertip off with it.

That aside, we picked the Bron when we lost the blades for the cheep-o madolin. It cost about $100 and, while I can't say it is four times better than the inexpensive version, it was much cheaper than other "professional" mandolins and a delight to cook with.

[edsel]

Kyocera makes a plastic slicer with a ceramic blade that's razor-sharp. It's on the small side and doesn't have interchangeable blades. They make a separate julienne slicer which I haven't tried. Not as versatile as one with interchangeable blades, but there are fewer parts to get lost in the utensile drawer.

[chezcherie]

Kyocera makes a plastic slicer with a ceramic blade that's razor-sharp. It's on the small side and doesn't have interchangeable blades. They make a separate julienne slicer which I haven't tried. Not as versatile as one with interchangeable blades, but there are fewer parts to get lost in the utensile drawer.

i recently used one of these kyocera slicers for the first time. it is very small, and non-adjustable, but i found it nifty, in that the blade is elevated, and sharp on both sides, so that you can make a cut on the downstroke, then another cut as you slide the food back up--kinda double-barreled, as it were.

edited for terrible typing

[edsel]

i recently used one of these kyocera slicers for the first time. it is very small, and non-adjustable, but i found it nifty, in that the blade is elevated, and sharp on both sides, so that you can make a cut on the downstroke, then another cut as you slide the food back up--kinda double-barreled, as it were. 

Yeah, the Kyocera really isn't a mandoline. It's small and non-adjustable and doesn't do julienne or waffle-cuts. However, you can get the slicer and the julienne cutter for under forty bucks - that qualifies as "cheap" in my book. Since Nikki mentioned that she wanted to make thin slices fast I thought that the Kyocera might be of interest. For something more versatile the benriner-style gadget is probably a better choice.

[irodguy]

I own and use a SS Bron, the only complaint I have is that it takes a little work go clean it.

If I need to do a small batch of slicing, I use a knife. Both of these devices need practice.

If you purchase a Mandoline for home use then don't take the safety off. Practice and when you get really comfortable toss the safety.

When large batches of potatoes I slice until it gets kind of small then go on to the next one. Then I go back with a towel to complete the slicing operation on the smallish pieces.

Yes I have sliced myself in the past, part of learning respect for your mandoline.

[Smithy]

I own two mandolins:  The French-made, stainless-steel Bron Professional requires that the cook devote sufficient time to become proficient in its use.  I use the Zyliss V-type slicer much more frequently.  It’s well-designed & durably constructed from ABS plastic & polycarbonate plastics, so it will stand up to tough usage.  The V-slicer is ideal for making rapid processing of vegetables for mirepoix, for slicing apples for tarts, or onions for chowder. The food holder properly secures items such as cucumbers & zucchini for longitudinal cutting. Thin or thick slicing, julienne or batonnet – all in all, a tool which I would recommend for anyone’s batterie de cuisine.

I tried the Zyliss recently and kept having problems with the slices jamming at the deepest part of the V. It seems as though the V makes a pinch point, right at what's usually the thickest part of the object to be sliced. After messing with trying to slice potatoes and eggplant, I gave up on it.

Anyone else have that problem, or did I have a bad V-cutter? Surely it wasn't operator error!

[halland]

If you're feeling daring, and have good insurance, try the famous Feemsters Vegetable Slicer.

Hal

[winesonoma]

Find the Cooks catalog one day sale thread. They have one on sale today only. it is
http://www.chefscata...0000&cmCat=Here

Edited by winesonoma, 21 September 2004 - 04:23 PM.

[fiftydollars]

I have a Benriner. It doesn't do waffle cuts, but the cuts it does it does very well.

I also purchased a $30 mandoline from Fantes and it is worth much more to me than the money I paid for it. I recommend you give it a try.

[Smithy]

I'm pulling this back up to the top to see if someone will answer. The V-blade mandolines look to me as though they have an automatic pinch point (the apex of the V) right at the thickest part of most items you'd be slicing. The one time I tried a Zyliss V-slicer, I did end up with stuff getting stuck and breaking off right there, instead of slicing neatly. What a pain - I went back to my knife and my not-quite-perfect slices to finish.

Has anyone else had this experience? Has someone here researched the issue of blade angle to performance? It looks to me as though a slightly angled blade - not straight across the holder, but going all in one line instead of a V, would be the optimal geometry.

Yours in equipment geekiness,
Nancy

[fifi]

Kyocera makes a plastic slicer with a ceramic blade that's razor-sharp. It's on the small side and doesn't have interchangeable blades. They make a separate julienne slicer which I haven't tried. Not as versatile as one with interchangeable blades, but there are fewer parts to get lost in the utensile drawer.

I have one of the julienne slicers. I bought it for the purpose of making jicama slaws and such. It cuts way too small and was very hard to use. It took a lot of pressure to cut jicama and basically turned it to mush. Since I have wanted a mandoline primarily for thin slicing and julienne, I think I am about to give it up. My new Kitchen Aid food processor has a large size grating disc that makes lovely squarish "straws" of carrot, jicama and such. I am probably going to get the julienne disc and reduce my chances of injury.

Thanks for bumping this up, Smithy. I was just talking to a friend the other day about which mandoline he ought to buy. He insists he has to have one. I have looked at the V slicers with the same question, but I have never tried one. It just seems like a bad way to go. I saw something on History Channel (I think) about the different designs that the French tried when perfecting the guillotine... straight, V shaped, slanted. They found the slanted blade to be superior. Can potatoes be any different than necks?

[andiesenji]

Is there a page anywhere with statistics on these mandolins? I want one to make 8mm slices of squash, but it's sometimes hard to find a product page that contains this specification. Any pointers?

Thanks,
Walt

---------------------------------------------------------

Well you won't have a problem with the Bron, there is a lever that you move one way or the other to get to whatever thickness you want, it is infinitely adjustable.
I have been using mine for many, many years. I have had the blades replaced once, about 8 or 9 years ago. When I am doing a big batch of something like cucumber slices for pickles, 20 pounds or so, I just set the Bron in one of the bus tubs (a rectangular tub available at Smart & Final or other restaurant supply places) and start in. I work sitting down, as this is usually a prolonged job, with the tub on a stool which I also use for holding very deep pots and etc., and onto the top of which I have tacked some of the non-slip shelf/drawer liner to hold it in place.

I have tried all of the knock-off slicers of every type and have never found one that works as well as the Bron. I paid 69.00 for the one I have, it still has the price on the end of the original box.

[Smithy]

---------------------------------------------------------
I have tried all of the knock-off slicers of every type and have never found one that works as well as the Bron.  I paid 69.00 for the one I have, it still has the price on the end of the original box.

Andie, was that $69 in 1970 dollars or $69 in 2000 dollars?

What I'm really getting at is, which version of the Bron do you have? The one I like the looks of best is, naturally, the most expensive version. I've never seen it for less than $100, and I'd rather have money left over for my next pot.

[winesonoma]

Try here $99.00 http://www.lionsre.com/.

[Smithy]

Try here $99.00 http://www.lionsre.com/.

Many thanks!

[Behemoth]

Any first person accounts on the OXO? I like most of their other stuff and I mandoline is next on the list (er, among other things...).

[JAZ]

Just saw the Oxo for the first time today when our rep demonstrated it (we don't yet have it in stock at Sur La Table, where I work, but supposedly it's on its way). It's got some good features and at $70 it's very reasonable.

Good points:

One removable blade with two edges - one straight and one waffle -- you just slide it out, flip it over and slide it back in.

Lower profile and better angle (to me at least).

A dial to adjust slice thickness and to pull up two julienne blades.

Not so great points:

A dial to adjust slice thickness and to pull up two julienne blades. Great idea; not so easy in practice. I couldn't tell if it was just that it was new, or if it was me, but the rep had trouble switching between the selections as well.

I don't know -- I have a German V-slicer and it works fine for what I need it for. For me, the only thing the Oxo does that mine doesn't do is waffle cuts, so it's not really worth it for me o upgrade. On the other hand, if I were purchasing my first, the Oxo would be a serious contender.

[Smithy]

I don't know, this post could go as easily into the "When Cheaper is Just Fine" thread, but I'm putting it here. Following Behemoth's lead (from the Dinner thread?) I decided to buy a cheap mandoline and see how I liked it. Progressive International makes it. It's plastic, with a guillotine-angled straight steel blade. (I still think that makes the most sense, and Fifi's information supports those notions.) It has 4 gizmos that snap in and out to adjust the size of the cut, and a couple of are reversible so there are effectively 7 different slicing or grating options. All told, this mandoline will do 3 slicing thicknesses, coarse or fine grating, julienne cuts or French fry cuts. I've been playing with it, and am delighted, and far more impressed than I was with the $50 Zyliss V-slicer I tried recently. Nothing jams. It's easy to clean. Who knows how well it will hold up? But for the price I can keep using and replacing it, and may only need to do so once a year....

It cost $8 at Cub Foods!

Use the finger guard. Even, or especially, if you're trying to get that last slice of pepper.

[Dani Mc]

I got the Oxo last week, and used it for the first time on potatoes for dinner tonight. Its fantastic. I've never owned a mandoline before, as they either looked to big and scary, or kinder egg surpise flimsy. This one is neither. Solid on the table-didn't have my usual fear that the thing was going to go flying off the counter, and I would somehow flay the skin from my forearm. Good size hand guard, and the blade selector is indeed easy to use. Jaz, I don't know what was wrong with your rep, I was able to grasp the concept immediately, and I am notorious for being kind of dumb in that department. Seen The Simpsons epi where Homer tries to put together the outdoor grill, gets frustrated, runs at it in a rage and just hammers the pieces together where he thinks they should fit? Thats me. I love oxo, because their stuff looks good, its durable, and the design is intuitive. I glanced at the instruction manual, but it was so obvious what did what, I could've thrown it out immediately. Great design team there.

Anyway, I've only used the plain slice setting, so I still have some playing to do, but even if I only use it to get perfect 1/8" potato slices, I'm happy with it. Definitely worth $70.

*edited because I just realized I actually spelled it 'potatoe'.

Edited by Dani Mc, 25 November 2004 - 10:45 PM.

[docsconz]

I'll second the Oxo. It is very easy to use and much more intuitive (and safe) than my more expensive one. For a home cook this one wins hands down.

[Behemoth]

I don't know, this post could go as easily into the "When Cheaper is Just Fine" thread, but I'm putting it here.  Following Behemoth's lead (from the Dinner thread?) I decided to buy a cheap mandoline and see how I liked it.  [etc]

It cost $8 at Cub Foods! 

Use the finger guard.  Even, or especially, if you're trying to get that last slice of pepper.

Smithy, just spotted this pot. Mine has an adjustable thickness dial, a bunch of different blade inserts, and works like a charm. I was really close to buying the Oxo, but this one was $20, and I used the $50 I saved to buy an All-Clad Masterchef 12-inch skillet (also at TJMaxx...)

[ASM NY]

I am getting a mandoline for my birthday but am unsure which brand to get. I currently own a "less expensive" model which I have been very unhappy with, so I feel like it's worth dishing out a little more cash for a higher quality brand.

Any thoughts?

[mharpo]

I've been very happy with my Bron - the massive model.

Edited by mharpo, 16 January 2006 - 01:59 PM.

[jgm]

I've owned three "less expensive" models, and I love my Oxo. If you really want to spring for something more expensive, there may well be merits in doing so. But the Oxo has met my needs well. There aren't a bunch of blades to switch out and keep track of. It's pretty much a self-contained unit, and for everyday slicing needs, it's an excellent value for the price.

[deltadoc]

My wife bought me one of those big 'ol expensive ones from Williams Sonoma, and I hate it. It is bulky, the blade didn't hold up and has nicks in it. It didn't slice food very well, it's hard to wash, hard to set up, and my Wusthof Trident Chef's knife does everything better anyway, faster, less mess, and easy cleanup.

doc

[cookman]

The Benriner Mandoline is well-made and very inexpensive. It is available in two sizes.

Here's a link to one source for it:
http://www.amazon.co...glance&n=284507

[Jason Perlow]

I've owned three "less expensive" models, and I love my Oxo.  If you really want to spring for something more expensive, there may well be merits in doing so.  But the Oxo has met my needs well.  There aren't a bunch of blades to switch out and keep track of.  It's pretty much a self-contained unit, and for everyday slicing needs, it's an excellent value for the price.

I concur, we recently purchased an Oxo, and it makes amazing gauffretes and does a great slicing job.

[snowangel]

A quick title search for Mandolines reveals several topics.

I have a cheapie. It's OK, but I'm happier with my knife. Perhaps I would notice a difference if I had a great one.

[BryanZ]

I also use an OXO and find it to be merely okay. It's certainly functional, but I wish the blades were sharper.

[dougery]

The Benriner Mandoline is well-made and very inexpensive. It is available in two sizes.

Here's a link to one source for it:
http://www.amazon.co...glance&n=284507

Benriner is definitely the way to go!