Jump to content

Welcome to the eG Forums!

These forums are a service of the Society for Culinary Arts & Letters, a 501c3 nonprofit organization dedicated to advancement of the culinary arts. Anyone can read the forums, however if you would like to participate in active discussions please join the society.


Great NY Noodletown


  • Please log in to reply
49 replies to this topic

#1 lxt

  • participating member
  • 310 posts

Posted 11 November 2002 - 09:46 AM

At the time one is puzzled by the perplexing question of the first Creation of the earth and of man, or troubled about the sources of defeat or victory and success or catastrophe in the Iliad and the Odyssey, some of us are simply pursuing a passion toward the baby pig. Of several conversations I had with Ms. X (an eGullet dining companion), there was none that did not contain a reference to the baby pig she recently tried at New York Noodle Town. Well, since Montaigne wisely noted that among three classes of philosophers (those who claim to have found the truth; those who deny that truth can be found; and those who confess their ignorance and go on searching) only the last are wise, we decided to pursue our search for the truth about the perfect baby pig by setting a lunch date to be held at New York Noodle Town.

Using self-exploration to help illuminate the world may be quite noble in some instances but very disturbing in others. In my case, not taking into consideration the late hour we set for the lunch and leaving the house with nothing but three grapes consumed in a hurry, which added to a quite elaborate symphony successfully conducted by my stomach while passing by China town’s cozy little restaurants and cafés with their enticing smells teasing my senses with the provocative images of delightful and tempting food, wasn’t very smart. Well, the good thing about the bad thing is that everything comes to an end, and, in my case, it was the end of my sufferings as soon as the three of us were seated at a cozy table for four.

“I am so hungry! All I had today were three grapes,” said Ms. X while browsing the menu. If one could ever think of a better time to start believing in fate or telepathy or any other weird stuff, that certainly was a good one. Not just any hunger, but the “hunger of three grapes” and the thoughts of the baby pig added a communal sense, and bonded us for life.

We ordered:
Barbecued baby pig
Salt baked seafood combination
Roast duck with flowering chives
Sizzling casserole with chicken and Chinese sausage

The baby pig served at room temperature was certainly a star. A nearly perfect execution of crisp skin and tender baby flesh provoked no less than cute little sounds of satisfaction exchanged among us all, not overlapping but rather creating a perfect harmony. The meat was a little tiny bit too salty for me, but again, I may just be a supertaster.:hmmm:

The salt baked seafood combination wasn't as good as I remembered it from two years ago. More or less crisp while still hot, it turned soggy upon cooling, like a balloon losing air.

The roast duck with flowering chives was very good indeed. Not as crisp as it would’ve been had we ordered duck separately from the chives, the meat was very tender and added a certain ducky flavor to the chives that was definitely worth trying. What I liked the most was that the dish was not overwhelmed with the flavor of the brown starch sauce, contrary to what we had at New Lok Kee in Flushing.

The sizzling casserole was quite sizzling when it was brought to our table. We all agreed that it wasn’t spectacular, but pretty good. To be fair, though, we were quite full by that time.

I’ll let others chime in with more details.

Overall, the food made us happy, and that is probably the best praise one can give. As to Montaigne, he was wrong. We did find the truth about the perfect baby pig in New York Noodle Town.:smile:
  • Plantes Vertes likes this

#2 Suzanne F

Suzanne F
  • legacy participant
  • 7,398 posts
  • Location:NY, NY

Posted 11 November 2002 - 08:15 PM

Lxt, while I personally was set on the path to intellectual maturity (whether or not I ever reach it is debatable, although not, regrettably, in this venue) via the Cartesian system of reasoning, I must say that I found your analysis quite compelling. And on the basis of my own bi-weekly research, I concur with many of your conclusions.

My own encounter with the baby pig occurred on 7 June of this year. The meat was over rice; I was over joy with the succulence of the flesh and the brittle perfection of the rind/skin. I might be in concordance with you about the salinity of the animal, but its juxtaposition against steamed rice mitigated any negative sensing.

Of "salt-baked" preparations, I have only experienced the soft-shell crabs, at the height of their season. I could not say if the crisp texture was lost over time, because we snarfled the creatures up with such rapidity that they had no chance even to cool. God, they were fabulous in their simplicity!

The lack of crispness to the duck on chives could be attibuted to the circumstance of the portion of duck having been nuked. But my consort and I have found over the last several months that the TASTE of the duck is getting better and better, with a greater proportion of bbq flavor to the rich duck flavor. (However, their duck still does not quite live up to the memory of ones purchased in years past from a cart on Canal Street -- although the price at NY Noodletown is still well below that of the cart adjusted upwards for inflation.)

I am a bit befuddled by the description of the casserole. We have on several occasions partaken of a sizzling casserole of Chinese sausages and TARO, but never one with the former plus chicken. Ours has always sizzled gratifyingly, and offered the additional pleasure of caramelized sauced taro, made so by the heat of the clay pot. Then again, we usually receive and eat that first, while we can still appreciate the kitchen's handiwork.

As for philosophy, I will continue to question, gather information, and analyze before I attempt to reach any conclusions about the perfection of the baby pig, or any other dishes, at NY Noodletown. As the advertisements used to say, "Getting there is half the fun."

#3 lxt

  • participating member
  • 310 posts

Posted 12 November 2002 - 10:00 AM

Of "salt-baked" preparations, I have only experienced the soft-shell crabs, at the height of their season. I could not say if the crisp texture was lost over time, because we snarfled the creatures up with such rapidity that they had no chance even to cool. God, they were fabulous in their simplicity!

Suzanne, soft-shell crabs were what attracted me to New York Noodle Town originally, and for several years I enjoyed the superb execution: very delicately crusted creatures were cooked crisp and until medium brown. The starch was almost transparent and added a special crunch without interfering with the taste of the crabs. In fact, their salt-baked preparation technique was so good that the seafood combination was no less delightful when the crabs were sold out. However, it seemed that they’ve changed their approach and the sogginess we observed this time has been persistent for about a year. That, actually, was one of the reasons we discarded our loyalty to the place during the soft-shell season this year.

The lack of crispness to the duck on chives could be attibuted to the circumstance of the portion of duck having been nuked.

If you don’t order duck separately, the preparation requires duck to be sautéed along with the flowering chives which takes the crispiness away and adds some moisture to the meat. The dish also has a light sauce. In my opinion, it is just a matter of preference. I did like, however, the smoky taste the flowering chives acquired from being married to duck.

I am a bit befuddled by the description of the casserole. We have on several occasions partaken of a sizzling casserole of Chinese sausages and TARO, but never one with the former plus chicken. Ours has always sizzled gratifyingly, and offered the additional pleasure of caramelized sauced taro, made so by the heat of the clay pot. Then again, we usually receive and eat that first, while we can still appreciate the kitchen's handiwork.

My recollection of the casserole could’ve been influenced by the fact that we were quite full at the time. However, I just didn’t think that the dish added any new flavors to our order. Though the sizzling effect was quite pleasing, I thought that chicken was a little gamy (though my companions may disagree) and the brown starch sauce used in a preparation seemed too similar to the duck dish we had earlier. But again, that is only if you want to be picky; otherwise, the dish was quite comforting. Thank you for the suggestion of Chinese sausages and taro.

As for philosophy, I will continue to question, gather information, and analyze before I attempt to reach any conclusions about the perfection of the baby pig...

As for philosophy and the baby pig, as they say: “The truth is out there.” :smile:

#4 ahr

  • participating member
  • 482 posts

Posted 12 November 2002 - 12:38 PM

The beautiful pig at Great NY Noodle Town (to give the restaurant its full, recently updated due) is served with a small dish of hoisin sauce, a nice sweet complement generally ignored in the rush to disappear the meat; there’s also a small pool of salty, soy-based sauce beneath the pig on the serving dish. The flowering chives were delicious the last two times I had them, despite being flowerless during flowering season. The chicken and sausage casserole is on the permanent “specials” list below the regular menu under the glass tabletop, and includes some unannounced black mushrooms that lend a smoky, earthy undertone. The salt-baked dishes (which are neither baked nor especially salty) can be variable, but even when the crust is insufficiently crisp, the seafood within is tender and juicy when consumed immediately.

Edit: Adjective addition.
"To Serve Man"
-- Favorite Twilight Zone cookbook

#5 Toby

  • legacy participant
  • 780 posts
  • Location:New York

Posted 12 November 2002 - 11:06 PM

Three visits to NY Noodletown in the last few weeks -- the first was late at night and they were out of baby pig, so ordered the baked pig, which had nice crunchy crisp skin but rather dry meat. Went back a week later in the afternoon for the baby pig. It was wonderful -- moist, juicy meat and paper-thin very crisp skin. Went back again the next week and again it was delicious, although I thought the skin this last time was slightly thicker with more fat underneath and not as wonderful, although I was making a lot of very satisfied sounds while eating. Lxt is right, the roasted duck is chopped and brought back to the kitchen where it's stir-fried along with the chives. One time some excellent very thin-fleshed mushrooms were added to the dish.

I've been obsessed with finding excellent salt and pepper squid in New York for the past five years, after having become completely addicted to the preparation in Yuet Lee in San Francisco. Yuet Lee's salt and pepper squid is fried to a beautiful brown color and is quite peppery and impossible to stop eating. All the salt and pepper squid (and combinations of squid, shrimp and scallop) I've eaten in New York have been a very pale color and not particularly spicy. The seafood itself at NY Noodletown was good, but the coating was too pale, not enough salt and pepper, and the scallops got soggy very fast. I feel that I'm doomed to be disappointed, although now I have a place to satisfy my new addiction for baby pig.

I liked the chicken and sausage casserole, although I would have preferred it if the chicken had been chopped through the bone and the bone included.

Has anyone tried any of the noodle soups at NY Noodletown?

#6 Pan

  • eGullet Society staff emeritus
  • 15,546 posts
  • Location:East Village, Manhattan

Posted 02 January 2003 - 02:40 AM

Has anyone tried any of the noodle soups at NY Noodletown?

Sure. Greater NY Noodletown (its current name, I think) may not be quite as good as it used to be, but I still like it and go there at less-crowded times for some items I like and find to be more or less comfort food. My standby noodle soup there is beef muscle (shrimp) wonton, which I sometimes get with the Chinese greens (Chinese broccoli) and oyster sauce side dish. I've had various other noodle soups. Beef stew is tasty but a bit rich (fatty); the fish dumplings are good; the shrimp dumplings are good, and they used to make a beef muscle/shrimp dumpling combination for me, but I've given up on getting it anymore; the tripe is just OK; and it's been so long since I've had duck or any other noodle soup that I don't remember it, except for the seaweed soup, which I thought was fine but haven't been really interested in trying a second time. The ginger/scallion lo mein are worth mentioning. I like them a lot and sometimes have them instead of a noodle soup and get a side order of beef muscle, tripe, soy sauce chicken, or duck on the side (I have to be pretty hungry for that).

If you want fast service, go to Bo Ky on Bayard between Mott and Mulberry, which serves a nice variety of noodle soups, though of a different cuisine (Chao Zhou) than the Hong Kong style at NY Noodletown. There's also a Chao Zhou restaurant on the west side of Mott St. near Grand. I had a good meal there 2 or 3 months ago, but I don't remember its name. I don't know why, but Chao Zhou restaurants in Chinatown give menus in Chinese, English, and Vietnamese, or at least those two do.

#7 Suzanne F

Suzanne F
  • legacy participant
  • 7,398 posts
  • Location:NY, NY

Posted 02 January 2003 - 09:48 AM

Has anyone tried any of the noodle soups at NY Noodletown?

Absolutely! The only problem I have is that I so love the ones I've tried, I have trouble getting around to trying others. A particular favorite is the seaweed noodle soup, which in addition to a fairly subtle stock, some seaweed, and a huge amount of noodles, also includes several wonton (with WHOLE shrimp), a boiled fish ball, another kind of fish ball that seems to have been fried first, and some sort of very peppery meat(?) ball. For $3.95, I find it unbeatable. We also often get the roast duck wonton soup, with a variably duck-flavored stock, noodles, the same shrimp wonton, and about a half-dozen pieces of roast duck.

#8 Steve Silkin

Steve Silkin
  • legacy participant
  • 37 posts

Posted 02 January 2003 - 12:13 PM

I have never understood what the fuss was about NY Noodletown. I have found the bbq meats to be average at best and the seafood'vegetables to be lousy. The place is also dirty and unpleasant. A better choice for bbq meats and Cantonese food in general is Family Noodle. Try the roast duck and you'll be in luck.

#9 marcus

  • participating member
  • 629 posts

Posted 03 January 2003 - 02:16 PM

I continue to find that NY Noodletown is the best restaurant of its type in Manhattan, I don't know about Flushing. The food is not transcendent and it can be inconsistent, but I have followed many recommendations over the years to purportedly better options, but never found them to be as good. I always end up going back. I also think that its just as good as it alway was, as is Joe's Shanghai, another restaurant that many feel has declined. In general, my view is that the disappointment growing out of inconsistency is the real cause of these reactions, rather than any overall long term change. The wonton soup, particularly without the noodles, can be wonderful, and the baby pig is more often than not, excellent. I also like their congee.

#10 bpearis

  • participating member
  • 561 posts
  • Location:NYC

Posted 19 February 2004 - 10:00 AM

I have to say I've never had a bad dish at Noodletown.
"If it's me and your granny on bongos, then it's a Fall gig'' -- Mark E. Smith

#11 Suzanne F

Suzanne F
  • legacy participant
  • 7,398 posts
  • Location:NY, NY

Posted 19 February 2004 - 12:08 PM

I guess it's one of those "Love it or hate it" places. HWOE and I love it (and my defense of its staff got me banned from chowhound some years ago); others now departed hated it.

I cannot say that everything there has been nectar and ambrosia (on rare occasions, the soup stock has been a bit funky), but on the whole, I find the food fresh and reliably good. We even had our first experience of Chinese tablemates asking what WE (very definitely non-Chinese) were eating because it intrigued them (for the record, it was the lamb and bean curd skin casserole, which is always delicious).

#12 PoorLawyer

  • participating member
  • 184 posts

Posted 19 February 2004 - 02:53 PM

Has anyone tried any of the noodle soups at NY Noodletown?

I am a big fan of the noodle soups there, especially the roast pork and wonton noodle. The wontons almost explode in your mouth, and what can be said about roast pork except that it is one of the greatest creations in the world. They have a great rich broth too that I can't stop slurping up!
I also like their salt-baked dishes, but only get the squid because I don't like the consistency of the scallops in that type of dish.

#13 lxt

  • participating member
  • 310 posts

Posted 19 February 2004 - 04:13 PM

One of the challenges of a small authentic restaurant, when the turnover in the kitchen is habitual, is consistency. I have the same problem recommending Russian restaurants where you are not quite sure whether the tender and sumptuous duck in a thin, delicately sweet cranberry sauce that you had the night before will be replaced today by a tough turkey with a thick, jam-like paste, in the hope that the diner will not notice the difference. Pathetically, in most cases, diners either don’t notice or much care, seeking rather the entertainment that Russian restaurants provide along with food.

My experience with NYNT is limited to only several dishes, which I found pleasing and which were the main reason for my consistent return. When the quality would fluctuate between very good and acceptable with occasional pleasant treats like soft-shells (as of several years ago) and baby pig, it was worth the effort. However, when the level of acceptable plunges to offensive, then the potential dissatisfaction is simply not worth the energy. Perhaps NYNT can still perform well, but my last meal with slimy shrimp was not only unappealing, it was almost repulsive. I still wonder how my companion actually managed to eat most of that dish. Pperhaps hunger adjusts one’s perception. After many visits, this was my first very unfortunate experience with NYNT, but the deterioration in the quality of the dishes I used to order on a regular basis over the years was quite obvious, and I doubt I’ll be inclined to try my luck again. I’d be curious to hear more recent positive comments as I still maintain a certain sentimental attachment to the place.

#14 Suzanne F

Suzanne F
  • legacy participant
  • 7,398 posts
  • Location:NY, NY

Posted 19 February 2004 - 08:41 PM

Oh my. lxt, I respect you opinion, so I'll have to pay more attention the next time. (We haven't been since 2/2. Honestly, we are there at least 3 times a month, sometimes every week.)

#15 kinichiwa

  • participating member
  • 37 posts

Posted 20 February 2004 - 07:29 PM

Small story about NYNT...
we dine at NYNT alot but ALWAYS for chinese new year... my neice was about 6 yrs. old when sitting in the dining room we saw the baby pig being brought up front in all its glory. it was all set out on a red tray and i explain to her that this was a new years moment that everyone enjoyed.
"Everyone", she said, "EXCEPT the poor pig!"
i must add that she enjoyed it 10 minutes later

i really like this restaurant, but as with every restaurant it has it's ups and downs. Even with that in mind, i still have not had a bad meal yet and i have been dining here for over 7 years

#16 kurl

  • participating member
  • 258 posts
  • Location:Brooklyn

Posted 25 April 2004 - 03:22 PM

As part of my apparent make-myself-miserable-about-the-sorry-state-of-food-in-St.-Louis mission, I've been planning a visit to NY Noodletown at some point soon after I return to New York over the summer.

Are there any recommended ways to minimize the chance of a bad meal? Arrive early? Late? On Tuesdays only?

Also, what dishes are essential? The roast baby pig comes up a hell of a lot, as does the salt-baked squid. Anything else? Mushroom noodle soup?

Edited by kurl, 25 April 2004 - 03:23 PM.

#17 victornet

  • participating member
  • 196 posts

Posted 25 April 2004 - 04:02 PM

Once a year we give large all-day-eating party at my parents' apartment (formerly a New Year's Day fest, we decided some years ago that too many people were hung over and not ready to really eat.) We've generally featured a roast baby pig (with a bagel in it's mouth) purchased in Chinatown, but it has indeed been the hardest course to source. (No PhD needed to buy smoked sturgeon at Barney Greengrass for example)

I started getting the pig at Great NY Noodletown a couple of years ago, and now the entire thing quickly disappears from the table. We always looked for the smallest pig, and last month they got me a 10 pounder, our smallest yet, and very delicious and tender.

#18 jo-mel

  • participating member
  • 1,633 posts
  • Location:New Jersey via Massachusetts

Posted 25 April 2004 - 04:21 PM

It's been years since I've had roast pig at NYNT, and that was at a banquet there with a group from The New School. But it was that banquet that brought me back, time and time again, because of their Casserole of Oysters and Roast Duck. I have kept the menu, and that dish has a big star beside it.

Once on a cold, rainy day, I sat near the cold, breezy, opening and closing door, but was warmed by that dish. I also love the Chicken/Sausage Casserole.

But my question here is of a different bent. I got to know one of the waiters (manager?) there, and if it wasn't busy, he would sit and talk. About a year before 9/11 he said that he was not happy with the owner, and was thinking of opening his own place -- over by Joe's Shanghai, and hoped we would follow as he thought he would be bringing some of the chefs, and the dishes, with him. Then came 9/11. In my visits at NYNT since then I haven't seen him, nor has the place he pointed out where he would locate, developed into a resturant.

Anyone else hear of this?

#19 Pan

  • eGullet Society staff emeritus
  • 15,546 posts
  • Location:East Village, Manhattan

Posted 25 April 2004 - 04:30 PM

I think of New York Noodle Town as a solid Chinese diner. Anyone who doesn't want that shouldn't go there. There are quite a number of inexpensive places in Chinatown that arguably have better food overall, and some of them also have a slightly less dinerish ambiance.

I've eaten at NYNT for the last 15 years or something, and all the waiters know me there, but I've been there less in the last 2-3 years as I've been slightly less satisfied with the beef muscles in their Beef Muscle Wonton Noodle Soup and have been enjoying Yeah Shanghai and some other places around the neighborhood. But it's still a good place. My advice to kurl is to get their excellent Ginger Scallion Lo Mein, and otherwise, order most anything that seems a little elaborate, like stuff with chives in it, for example. Consider the dishes in casseroles, too. And anything salt-baked is likely to please. The basic menu is underneath the glass on the table, but don't overlook the double-sided specials menus that are on the table. I don't recommend the wide noodles, though - too oily and not interesting enough in terms of taste (mostly oil taste, in my experience).

#20 ahr

  • participating member
  • 482 posts

Posted 26 April 2004 - 04:22 PM

A quick, satisfying, and unbalanced lunch at Great NY Noodletown during a visit last week to Great NY City:Crispy, moist, savory roast duck;
Enormous (ENORMOUS), sweet, crispy, juicy salt-baked soft-shelled crabs; and
Delicious flowerless flowering chives with more of that beautiful duck, some mushrooms, and a bit of brown sauce. (Sorry, but the Adjective Police tell me that I've exhausted my quota for the day.)
Oh, and a little bit rice, Atkins forgive me, so I shouldn't go hungry.

Pondering the meal afterwards, I realized that despite the enormity and excellence of the crabs, something was just naggingly missing. That something was browned butter.
"To Serve Man"
-- Favorite Twilight Zone cookbook

#21 eatpie

  • participating member
  • 68 posts

Posted 27 April 2004 - 06:43 AM

Damn, I had 2 incredible soft shell crabs from NYNT last night. Perfect, huge, satisfying, orgasmic, crispy...Im running out of adjectives.

The other highlight of the meal was a mixed Seafood Casserole. Nice combination of conch, non-tenderized octopus, prawns, squid, tofu and a few veggies. in a powerful ginger based sauced. Highly recommend this dish.
"Your girlfriend is a vegetarian, tell her she should eat rabbit...they're vegetarians too" Ali

#22 Jason Perlow

Jason Perlow
  • eGullet Society staff emeritus
  • 13,511 posts
  • Location:FL

Posted 09 September 2005 - 02:26 PM

JHLurie and I had our first visit to Great NY Noodletown yesterday during lunch -- we started off with the Char Siu roast pork, which was succulent as all get out, and had the very wide noodles with chicken, finishing up with Beef and Chicken with Celery in XO sauce in a birds nest. The really fresh celery was key to the enjoyment of the dish.

I feel ashamed I've been reading about it all these years and never went -- I'll definitely be going back.

I brought back a pound of Char Siu and a half a Soy Sauce Chicken, which has been sitting in my office refrigerator overnight... Gonna make some hardcore fried rice with that pork this weekend, I garontee.
Jason Perlow
Co-Founder, The Society for Culinary Arts & Letters
offthebroiler.com - Food Blog | My Flickr photo stream

#23 peter_nyc

  • participating member
  • 158 posts
  • Location:New York

Posted 11 September 2005 - 01:21 PM

Gave NYNoodleTown a shot this afternoon. Ordered the wonton with "beef meat" soup and the shrimp dumpling soup. The kitchen accidentally swapped the dumplings and so I ended up with shrimp dumpling with "beef meat" soup and wonton soup, and the "beef meat" was actually beef tendon, but both soups were delicious anyway.

#24 jhlurie

  • eGullet Society staff emeritus
  • 6,300 posts

Posted 11 September 2005 - 03:54 PM

I was actually pretty impressed with the place. If it's quality has fallen, then it's a real shame, but I was still pretty happy.

The roast pork WAS a tiny bit inconsistent. About a third of it was a bit dry, but the rest was, as Jason reports, quite succulent. The dry part seemed to be in the middle, while the edges were the moist parts.

Beef and Chicken with Celery in XO sauce was indeed great (although I'm never attempting to eat one of those rice bird's nests again!). Celery can be one of the most disgusting vegetables in the world if it sits around, but the stuff in this dish tasted just picked (or at least recently picked). The beef was also sauteed with a very light hand, which I appreciated.
Jon Lurie, aka "jhlurie"

#25 Pan

  • eGullet Society staff emeritus
  • 15,546 posts
  • Location:East Village, Manhattan

Posted 11 September 2005 - 05:15 PM

I was actually pretty impressed with the place.  If it's quality has fallen, then it's a real shame, but I was still pretty happy.[...]

View Post

Hey, I'm one of the people who's said that, and all that means is that it used to be even better. :biggrin:

But if you have luck ordering or they're cooking on all cylindars on that day, it'll be as good as it ever was.

#26 mascarpone

  • participating member
  • 503 posts

Posted 13 September 2005 - 07:00 AM

As I am not a seafood expert by any means, I wondered if a better (food-per-value) Soft shell crab entre exists in New York. I have been continually impressed with the size and quality of Soft-shell Crabs at GNYNT for several years running. Does anyone do two huge SS Crabs better for $15, or is GNYNT the place?

Edited by mascarpone, 13 September 2005 - 07:04 AM.

#27 Daniel

  • legacy participant
  • 4,513 posts
  • Location:Manhattan

Posted 25 November 2006 - 09:11 PM

Went there for dinner tonight at 8 ish.. There was a five minute wait for a table of four..

Posted Image

They were out of BBQ Baby Pig so we ordered the roast pork.. This is just so good.. Crispy salted skin, the meat was not dry and had a sweet soy/wine flavor..The skin had a great crunch to it..

Posted Image

Next, came egg rolls which are not pictured.. Actually they were duck rolls.. Please get them when you go there.. They are really good with the red vinegar also.. After the duck rolls came salt baked shrimp.. We asked for a side of ginger scallion sauce.. It also comes with the poached chicken but we think it goes very well with the shrimp..

Posted Image

Poached chicken with ginger scallion sauce.. This is a white sauce with ginger scallion as opposed to the ginger scallion in oil sauce we ordered with the shrimp ..

A simple poached chicken breast..Really nice dish..

Posted Image

We had also ordered snails in XO Sauce, but they were out this evening.. Finally this dish was for the little one.. Its your basic pan fried noodle.. As good as you would have it anywhere..

Posted Image

The place is solid and not too expensive.. The roast or barbecued pork and duck are amazing.. The spareribs as well.. The duck rolls are worth the trip alone.. All the food with 4 beers was 65 bucks.. But thats the thing about Chinese Food or Family style for that matter.. Whether its three or six of you the price is going to be basically the same.. Its right on the Bowery, I parked in a lot outside and walked half a block to the restaurant..

For dessert we went to Blau Gans down on Duane St.. A couple of coups and I am too full to move..

Edited by Daniel, 26 November 2006 - 07:37 AM.

#28 chetlemon

  • participating member
  • 7 posts

Posted 19 March 2007 - 07:54 AM

I've eaten here about a dozen times over the last few months, most recently this past weekend for dinner.

While there have not been a lot of posts in the last year or so, many of the older comments still apply. Several of the dishes are great, but others are average or worse ... while this is my favorite Chinatown restaurant, I definitely would not recommend Noodletown to someone without giving them specific advice on what to order. (For instance, despite the name, the noodles are actually not the highlight in my opinion.)

Roast baby pig is outstanding, just like others have described with the thin layers of crispy skin and fat to go with the tender meat. They didn't have it the last time I was there, and in my opinion, the roast pork is not worth getting as a substitute (although I'll admit that what I tried didn't look as good as the roast pork in Daniel's picture, so maybe there's some variability here).

Roast duck is also great, better than any of the other places I've tried in Chinatown; I think it's best with either the flowering chives or pea shoots instead of as a stand-alone. I've also tried the pea shoots with other meats a couple of times (once chicken and once scallops), and these disesh were nowhere near the same level.

Most of the salt-baked seafood is great as well, except for the scallops, which are no good. So get the shrimp or soft-shell crab.

Finally, I tried the congee last time and thought it was very good, but I'm ashamed to admit that's the first time I've had congee, so I don't have much basis for comparison.

#29 Sneakeater

  • participating member
  • 4,455 posts

Posted 19 March 2007 - 07:59 AM

There's DEFINITELY variation in the roast pork. Sometimes it's excellent, sometimes it's not.

#30 Gastro888

  • participating member
  • 1,339 posts

Posted 19 March 2007 - 08:10 AM

The suckling pig here is quite good. Their noodle dishes are ok. I really want to try their version of e-fu mein with lobster. It looks great but I don't think I'd be able to finish it off by myself!

Also tagged with one or more of these keywords: Chinese