So last night began with a stop at a party at Henry's ex-boss's house in Madison. It was a posh cocktail party with open bars and lots of little nibbles. (Of course, I didn't take pictures as that would be rude.) I ate: pepper-crusted ahi, mini crab cakes, mini potato cakes, roast beef on crackers, heirloom tomato, basil and mozzarella, mini jerk chicken sandwiches...the list goes on. I drank a glass of wine and Henry had a martini.
We weren't all that hungry for dinner, but had to soldier on for the blog
First stop--Sitka and Spruce. CLOSED. Rats! (again!)
Since John wasn't at Lark (he was cooking at the Boomtown event), I suggested we go to
Elemental instead.
It's REALLY small inside--only 5 tables, and 2 seats at the bar.
The infamous Phred...
"Have a palate cleanser," he said.
We drank it. It was a sherry.
"Would you like to start off with cocktails?"
We said sure.
We asked him to bring us a few dishes of whatever he liked. I understand how some people would have a problem with the service, as Phred gave us each wine without any explanation. I didn't mind this, as I like guessing. I got the first wine correct! It was a Riesling.
The Riesling was paired with a crab and mango salad. It was very simple, but the quality of the food is good.
I should take this time to say that we had a wonderful evening yesterday night. However, none of the dishes we had were what Henry and I consider restaurant fare--as you will see in the pictures below, there are no fancy techniques or presentations here. In fact, I think most decent cooks could make stuff like this for regular weeknight meals. So in that respect, I wasn't really impressed. However, Elemental offers a very different experience in that the wine pairings are very generous and very good/excellent.
The next course was a chicken thigh dish with tamarind glaze and couscous. Phred poured us two wines each for this dish "for comparison purposes".
Based on the nose (and before tasting), I guessed that the first wine was a New World pinot and the second was an Old World burgundy. I got it half right--the first wine was a blend from Oregon and the second was an obscure wine from France.
We got a white wine with the next course (greens and hazelnuts).
We were falling behind on the drinking...at multiple times during the meal, there were like 8 glasses on the table for the 2 of us!
The crust was nice, but the crumb too spongy.
Lamb t-bones with walnut tapenade and roasted vegetables.
We drank two more glasses of red EACH with this dish.
Excellent cheese board. We each got a glass of white and a glass of red with the cheese. (Is anyone keeping count with how much wine we've had at this point?!!!!)
Phred insisted we have a dessert drink as well.

Just in case we didn't have enough alcohol with our meal, you know....
All in all, we both had a fantastic night. I do see how Elemental might rub some diners the wrong way. I think most diners would like to see a menu and choose their wines on their own--and I think they have every right to expect that as paying customers. At the same time, Henry and I both enjoy getting some direction from people much more knowledgable than we are about food/wine...we like to be educated at dinner, as that enhances our dining experience. Would I go back to Elemental? Possibly, for the cheese and wine...the food was solid, homecooking, and while it was tasty, it is not really something that appeals to either of us when we're dining out.
ETA: To clarify, Elemental does have menus, but we opted to let the kitchen choose for us, as we often do when we dine out.
This post has been edited by Ling: 30 August 2006 - 02:12 PM